Register

Mooney vs. Columbia Which is Really Faster?

Columbia claims its turbocharged 400 is the fastest piston single, but Aviation Consumer trials reveal that the Mooney Acclaim may actually be faster. Either way, both companies are using what we consider to be misleading marketing claims.

Wh

atever you might say positive or negative about general aviation, this much is certainly a constant: No one in the marketing department ever got their pants snagged worrying about truth in advertising. In the not-so-good old days, the POH performance numbers got a friendly burnishing from the marketing department and the lapdog aviation press played along. After all, what are a few knots of exaggerated cruise speed and missing payload among us enthusiasts? Were talking about airplanes, after all, so its all good, right?

Mooney Acclaim Vs. Columbia 400

New-age buyers-the kind who maybe started flying when Bill Clinton was still in the White House-arent so sanguine. If they drive a BMW or a Lexus, they actually expect things like competent customer service and airplanes that more or less perform as the manufacturers claim. But have the manufacturers sensed this and adjusted their marketing and sales hype accordingly? Mostly, they have, but they still try to slip by a fast one occasionally, which is what Colombia and Mooney are doing at the moment, in our view. In their sales material and Web sites, both are claiming to sell the fastest piston single-Columbia with its 400 and Mooney with its recently introduced Acclaim. Says Columbia on its Web site: “The Columbia 400 is faster than any other certified single-engine piston-powered aircraft on the planet, period.”

Like all such ad claims, these seem to have materialized out of the thin air the 400 and the Acclaim need to climb into to deliver the speed theyre selling. There’s no FAI certification, no Guinness Book of World Records certificate and not even so much as an asterisk explaining the details.